Mansion Sports – The encounter between Newcastle United and Manchester City in Week 12 of the 2025/2026 Premier League season at St James’ Park unfolded with high intensity and became a stage for Newcastle’s resurgence through the decisive performance of Harvey Barnes.

In a clash featuring two teams with contrasting ambitions, Manchester City arrived with strong momentum and a chance to narrow the gap on Arsenal at the top of the table.

City’s Dominance and Newcastle’s Efficiency

Although Manchester City controlled much of the possession, Pep Guardiola’s side struggled to convert the opportunities they created.

Newcastle, in contrast, displayed far greater efficiency when chances emerged. Barnes—initially under scrutiny due to two missed opportunities in the first half—ultimately transformed into the decisive figure of the match.

His two second-half goals became the separating factor in a contest that ended with a 2–1 victory for Newcastle.

The result not only halted Newcastle’s poor run of form but also delivered a significant setback to City’s title pursuit.

Barnes’ Resurgence and Key Decisions in the Second Half

The match was tightly contested from the opening minutes. Both teams generated notable chances in the first half, with Barnes and Erling Haaland drawing the most attention for failing to capitalize on clear opportunities.

Barnes squandered two promising chances, while Haaland remained unable to reach his 100th Premier League goal after several of his attempts were denied by Nick Pope.

After the interval, the criticism directed at Barnes shifted dramatically. In the 63rd minute, he unleashed a precise shot into the bottom-left corner from roughly 20 yards to give Newcastle the lead.

Manchester City equalized five minutes later through a goal from Ruben Dias, yet Barnes restored Newcastle’s advantage in the 70th minute when he converted a rebound following a header by Bruno Guimaraes.

The goal underwent a VAR review for potential offside and a possible foul but was ultimately upheld.

Match Statistics: Newcastle vs Manchester City

Table of match statistics